Sunday, March 09, 2003
8:30 PM | Posted by
E. Nough
Bitter Sanity says the UN will be torn apart by the fundamental misunderstandings between Europeans and Americans.
For Americans, protecting international security is the UN's purpose, its reason for being. Looking at the organization's recent history, we can see many instances in which it has failed to accomplish its purpose: the genocide in Rwanda, the incredible fuckup in Srebrenica, UN soldiers stepping aside and allowing the 1967 attack on Israel, and on and on. Clearly not much good at protection.That's just part of the introduction. Go read the whole thing. Found via Instapundit.
...The UN is not only not useful, it's become actively harmful - not in a trivial "Let's spout some anti-Semitic rhetoric today" way, but in a way that if allowed to succeed will have a real price in blood. To me - having grown up in Jefferson's tradition - it looks like "alter or abolish" time.
But what does it look like to Europeans? I think that Europeans see the UN's mission, not as ensuring security, but as acting as a check on unfettered nationalism. And I see this profound but unstated difference in perception of the UN's purpose as the underlying source of the current UN conflict.
Considering what European nationalism did to the twentieth century - not to mention the nineteenth, the eighteenth, and I could go on for a while - it's reasonable for them to have concluded that nationalism unrestrained is the evil that causes war. And to have turned, after the Second World War, to transnational organizations - the UN, the EC, the EU - as a way of putting chains on nationalism, of keeping it within bounds, of preventing it from ever again drawing the whole world into war. These organizations are entrusted with keeping the old demon of nationalism down, and so naturally, they must have a certain degree of authority over national governments.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(198)
-
▼
March
(26)
- Peace through strength revisited Hey, remember ...
- Saddam's Swimming Saboteurs A blurb in OpinionJ...
- There's a great new blog for quick links to late-b...
- Who needs Iraqi propaganda when you've got Reuters?
- Oh man... that is just brutal The Sun's treatme...
- If there is one word that sums up the events of th...
- It has begun. Godspeed to the American, British, ...
- Too much serious crap lately. Let's have a little...
- Just how dumb do you have to be, to copy someone e...
- The thing that has always irritated me about these...
- Sorry it's been so quiet around here. It's been a...
- Strange Google searches that have brought people h...
- More whining from Said Eddie Said has penned ye...
- OK, I understand the sentiment and all, but -- you...
- You can't make this stuff up AP reports that th...
- Bitter Sanity says the UN will be torn apart by th...
- Aww, shucks... I had no idea I was so interesting.
- To no great surprise on my part, the United Nation...
- NPR's Morning Edition had a really interesting (an...
- By way of Andrew Sullivan comes this bizarre story...
- John Hawkins -- posing as "HolyWarrior," an Iraqi ...
- Daniel Strimpel just worked his first day as a CAM...
- Cox and Forkum, authors of the LGF Fiskie Award to...
- So after being kicked off the air at ABC for sayin...
- A quick summary of the Arab League meeting in Shar...
- Dixie Flatline has written one of the best essays ...
-
▼
March
(26)
- Make Money Online
- Staunch Moderate
- Rittenhouse Review
- Work at Home News
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
- DipDot
- Second String Swap
- Investment Banking Monkey
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Bashhh
- TRR Blog
- Bloombox Reviews
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- Beadle Beads
- Glass Beads Supplies
- Paquet Full of Glass
- Native American Jewelry
0 comments:
Post a Comment